« Is Steinway worth it? » may be the single most recurrent question on piano forums. The answers from actual owners are more nuanced — and more useful — than the marketing or the backlash. We compiled them, as a companion to our price analysis.
What the premium actually buys
Steinway’s defenders in the threads are specific: a sound « lush and full of harmonics » that plays « like an orchestra », a one-piece bridge on the larger models, and a resale cachet no rival matches. Even owners who ultimately bought elsewhere concede the dynamic range of a good Steinway exceeded the Japanese challengers they tried.
The recurring complaint is not the piano
Strikingly, the criticism in these threads rarely targets the instrument’s design — it targets preparation. Several members report showroom examples poorly regulated or out of tune at audition; a technician notes that most professionals only consider the premium justified once the piano has been properly set up. Others observe that well-rebuilt older Steinways « sounded and played better than the new ones » they tried. The pattern matches what we found on the Model B: unit-to-unit variability is the real risk, and the showroom’s preparation effort is the real differentiator.
The challengers’ case
In the same threads, the case against paying the premium is equally concrete: a Shigeru Kawai owner three years in — tropical climate, heavy use — reports flawless service including the factory master-technician home visit; another member describes Shigeru build quality as « impeccable », while finding its tone « a bit nasal » against the Steinway’s. Mason & Hamlin, Bösendorfer, Grotrian and Sauter recur as value alternatives in the 200-220 cm class. The consensus formula: the challengers sell you an instrument; Steinway sells you an instrument plus an institution.
The takeaway
If the badge, the resale floor and the orchestral tone matter to you, the premium has a rationale — but make the dealer earn it: full regulation and voicing before purchase, several examples auditioned. If they do not, the same money buys an exceptional challenger with change to spare; our UK value guide runs the numbers.
Prepare to pay, or prepare to walk
The threads point to a clear buyer’s stance. If the badge, the resale floor and the orchestral tone genuinely matter to you, the Steinway premium has a rationale — but make the dealer earn it. That means full regulation and voicing before purchase, and several examples auditioned, because unit-to-unit variability is the real risk on these instruments. A poorly prepared showroom piano tells you little about what the model can do; a properly set-up one tells you everything.
When the challengers win
If the dealer will not do that work, the same money buys an exceptional challenger with change to spare. Shigeru Kawai, Mason & Hamlin, Bösendorfer, Grotrian and Sauter recur in the threads as value alternatives in the 200-220 cm class, several with service and build quality owners praise highly. The honest formula that emerges is simple: the challengers sell you an instrument; Steinway sells you an instrument plus an institution. Decide which of those you are actually paying for, and the choice clarifies itself.
Prestige and the resale floor
Part of what the premium buys is intangible but real: a resale cachet no rival quite matches, and a badge that carries weight in concert halls and institutions. For some buyers that liquidity and status genuinely factor into the decision, and it would be dishonest to dismiss them. Yet several voices in the threads temper the point — well-rebuilt older Steinways that outplayed new ones, real-world depreciation steeper than the official line. The sensible reading is to treat prestige as one component of value among several, alongside tone, action and preparation, rather than as a reason to skip the auditioning that any instrument at this level demands.
A note on method
This article synthesises public exchanges between pianists, owners and technicians on specialist forums (PianoWorld in particular), consulted in June 2026. Comments are paraphrased — never reproduced verbatim — and remain the opinions of their authors. We cross-check them against our own evaluation grid without conflating the two: our rating method documents our criteria.
Threads consulted:
- Is Model B worth the price? — PianoWorld
- Shigeru SK3 or Steinway M — PianoWorld
- Steinway vs Shigeru Kawai — PianoWorld
This page contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
🎹 Essential accessories for pianists
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.